£16 post free World-wide 555 sonatas 9Cds mp3 files Only £22 Benjamin: Written on Skin £16 Search What's New Previous CDs Concerts Jazz Nostalgia Composers Resources Announce Labels index Every day we post 10 new Classical CD and DVD reviews. A free weekly summary is available by e-mail. MusicWeb is not a subscription site. To keep it free please purchase discs through our links. Classical Editor Rob Barnett Founder Len Mullenger REVIEW Some items to consider Dunedin Consort Peter Grimes Hymn of Jesus: Sea Drift Complete Mozart Edition Mozart complete edition Vaughan Williams Symphonies 5 & 8 £11 Weiner, Klepper, Bloch, Schulhoff £12 post free [Wagner Edition - 25DVDs £71 post-free] [Get Happy] [Brahms and Schumann violin concertos £10] [Shostakovich Symphony 7] [Vanessa Benelli Mosell plays Liszt £5.05] [4CDs + 196 page book - £33 post-free world-wide - 15,000 copies sold] Available again Buy through MusicWeb for £18 postage paid (sale or return). Musicweb Purchase button Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750) Six Sonatas and Partitas for solo violin, BWV 1001-1006 (c. 1720) CD 1 Sonata No.1 in G minor, BWV 1001 [14:43] Partita No.1 in B minor, BWV 1002 [28:58] Sonata No.2 in A minor, BWV 1003 [20:55] CD 2 Partita No.2 in D minor, BWV 1004 [28:23] Sonata No.3 in C major, BWV 1005 [20:46] Partita No.3 in E major, BWV 1006 [18:14] Viktoria Mullova (baroque violin) rec. 18-19 March 2007, 20-22 October 2008, Bolzano, Italy. DDD ONYX CLASSICS 4040 [64:50 + 67:32] Experience Classicsonline I have been brought up on two principal recordings of the Sonatas and Partitas: Arthur Grumiaux from 1960 on Philips Classics Duo 438 736-2 and the 1973 version from Nathan Milstein on Deutsche Grammophon 'The Originals' 457 701-2. I played these recordings over and over again during my university studies having a slight preference for the account by Milstein for its additional refinement. In the early 1990s Mullova recorded the 3 Partitas on Philips 434 075-2 on a modern strung violin but not the 3 Sonatas. In the light of her discovery and subsequent embracing of period instrument performance Mullova would rather people now forget about the Grammy-nominated Philips recording. Having heard this quite remarkable new Onyx set I can quite understand her position. I am still basking in an afterglow of satisfaction. This is not the first recording to use using period instruments; not by any means. Probably the finest account has been from the impressively sensitive Rachel Podger on Channel Classics CCS SEL 2498. There are also two fine Naxos sets to consider from baroque violinists Jaap Schröder on 8.557563/64 and Lucy Van Dael on 8.554422/23. From her formative years in Russia as a student at the Moscow Conservatoire and for many years as a performer Mullova followed the tradition of playing the modern stringed violin and bow. Her Moscow teachers had laid down strictures for performing Bach. Mullova explains, “they were based on a widely-held approach of the time that combined a standardized, beautiful sound, broad, uniform articulation, long phrasing, if possible, and continuous vibrato on every note, in imitation, they used to say, of an imaginary organ.” From not even being aware that a period bow existed Mullova has gradually developed her passion for Baroque and Classical music performed on period instruments. Her epiphany occurred following an inspirational meeting in Paris with Baroque specialist the bassoonist and continuo player Marc Postinghel. Since then she has immersed herself in early music, working with several outstanding period instrument specialists: Ottavio Dantone, Giovanni Antonini, Andrea Marcon and Giuliano Carmignola. I recall Mullova's splendid 2001 recording from St. Jude's Church, London of Mozart's Violin Concertos 1, 3 and 4 both as soloist and director of the period instrument Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment on Philips 470 292-2. There she used a 'Jules Falk' Stradivarius from 1723 with gut strings and a period bow. For Onyx she recorded in 2004 at Cremona, a superb disc of Vivaldi's 5 Violin Concertos again using her cherished 'Jules Falk'. This was with the period instrument ensemble Il Giardino Armonico under Giovanni Antonini. I have fond memories of her 2007 Vivaldi collaboration at Toblach in the Italian Dolomites with Baroque violinist Giuliano Carmignola and the Venice Baroque Orchestra under Andrea Marcon (Archiv Production). On this new Onyx recording Mullova now favours her 1750 Giovanni Battista Guadagnini violin with gut strings, tuned down to A415 Hz. She uses a contemporary copy of a Baroque bow by Italian maker Walter Barbiero. Mullova does not take the authenticity obsessively far having her Guadagnini in a modern set-up that she feels does not adversely affect her interpretations. For those interested in a few historical details Johann Sebastian Bach probably commenced writing this collection of 6 Sonatas and Partitas for solo violin during his tenure with the Duke Wilhelm-Ernst of Sachsen-Weimar. In 1717 Bach was forced to leave the Ducal Court at Weimar. It was in 1720 whilst employed as Kapellmeister by Prince Leopold of Anhalt-Köthen at Köthen that Bach completed the set. The first disc here commences with the Sonata No.1 in G minor cast in the traditional four movement church sonata form. In the G minor score I was struck by the aching tenderness of the opening Adagio. The following Fuga: Allegro feels like a depiction of an unrelenting struggle against humanity. The short Siciliana is coquettish and nervy at times and I could easily picture a wooing ritual at the Ducal Court. Boisterous and extrovert, Mullova's playing of the concluding Presto is breathtaking with a real sense of risk-taking. The Partita No.1 in B minor is designed in chamber sonata form as an eight movement dance suite. To open the score the effervescent and elegantly performed Allemanda convincingly depicts a dancing scene at a Court Ball. Infused with incense, an air of sacred mystery hangs densely over the first Double. In the youthful exuberance of the Corrente one can easily imagine a scene of children of the nobility playing in the Court grounds. Breathtakingly fast, almost wilful playing from Mullova in the second Double marked Presto takes the listener to the brink of frenzy. By contrast the languid relaxation of the Sarabande is evocative of a lazy summer's day slumber. Strict and forthright Mullova demonstrates the finest manners in the third Double and with unrestrained vigour the joyful clamour of freedom is paramount in the Tempo di Borea. In the fourth and final Double Mullova provides whirling music of dizzying abandon. The Sonata No.2 in A minor opens with movement marked Grave significant for its mournful nature with aspects of reflective affirmation. Mullova's bright and uplifting playing shakes off the cobwebs in the Fuga resisting the temptation for even quicker speeds. I loved the exhilarating flourish for a few moments at 6:54. Mullova dedicates the tender and poetic Andante to her daughter Katia. Here I felt the music evocative of a narrative of hope and justice for mankind. There is brisk playing from Mullova in the final movement Allegro who twists, kneads and shapes this music of virile athleticism into an endless reverie. The second disc opens with the five movement Partita No.2 in D minor. The final movement of the D minor Partita is the monumental Ciaconna (Chaconne) designed as a theme and series of variations. Considered by many to be the summit of solo violin repertoire the Ciaconna is often played as an independent score. Of a disproportionate length to the other movements it has been suggested that the Ciaconna was written in remembrance of Bach's wife Maria Barbara. According to musicologist David Ewen the Ciaconna gives, “testimony to Bach's capacity to bring to his polyphonic writing whether for violin or cello, a wealth of emotion as well as thought.” ('The Complete Book of Classical Music', Pub: R. Hale, London, 1965). An Allemande opens the D minor Partita with an assured Mullova conjuring up a haunting atmosphere. In the following Corrente the soloist imparts a safe and comforting world of carefree ecstasy that contrasts with the somewhat starchy, serious and introspective central movement Sarabanda. Blistering playing of white-hot intensity from Mullova in the Giga demonstrates awesome technical mastery. In the darkly brooding character of the mighty Ciaconna I was struck by the astonishing playing, rapt with intense concentration and generating terrific emotional impact. Of the many highlights I especially enjoyed the fiendishly difficult fiery run at 12:49 - effortlessly played and completely glorious too. The Sonata No.3 in C major opens with an Adagio of a spare almost saturnine quality. In the extended Fuga Mullova communicates this profound and humane music as a powerful quasi-devotional utterance. I love the way Mullova's Guadagnini sings with aching tenderness amid the leafy light and shades of the Largo. In the final movement Allegro assai Mullova surges the music forward fervently with the radiant energy of a flaming beacon. The final disc of the set is the Partita No.3 in E major a seven movement score and the shortest Partita of the trio by some ten minutes. The well loved Preludio is often played as a separate recital piece. Technical distinction is a striking feature of Mullova's magnificent playing especially when woven with this elevated level of exhilaration and colourful drama. A distinct melancholy pervades the Loure without ever becoming cloaked in unwelcome sentimentality. Mullova sensuously phrases the extremely popular Gavotte en Rondeau a gravely beautiful outpouring. This is followed by the first Menuet, serene and mysterious in colour lavished with assiduous care for blend and balance. The second Menuet is gracefully performed with a distinctive purity and grace that invites admiration. I admired the glistening freshness of the short Bourrée abundant with vitality and rhythmic zest. The E major Partita and the whole programme concludes with the Gigue marked by Mullova's uplifting and determined playing of such striking presence that it reminded me of the boughs of a mighty oak resisting a determined gusty wind. I first became aware of this Mullova recording last week, alerted by the large amount of attention it was receiving at the listening booths at the renowned 'Ludwig Beck' department store in Münich. There I had time to hear a few excerpts on their TEAC player and Pioneer headphones and was immediately struck by the outstanding sonics. From subsequent hearings on my own set-up I can report a cool, crystal-clear sound with superb balance. Lacking in an informative essay about the actual scores this double set from Onyx is otherwise beautifully presented. There are a select number of very special discs of masterworks in my collection. I treasure these above all others; my 'Desert Island' discs, if you like. In this list I would include sets of the Chopin Ballades and Scherzos from Artur Rubinstein on RCA Red Seal Living Stereo; both the Haydn and Beethoven complete Piano Trios by the Beaux Arts Trio on Philips; J.S. Bach complete Sonatas for Violin and Harpsichord with Arthur Grumiaux and Christiane Jaccottet on Philips; Mendelssohn's complete String Quartets from the Henschel Quartet on Arte Nova; Mozart Piano Sonatas by Mitsuko Uchida on Philips; J.S. Bach The Well-Tempered Clavier by harpsichordist Kenneth Gilbert on Archiv Produktion; Beethoven complete String Quartets by the Takács Quartet on Decca and Schubert Winterreise performed by Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau and Jörg Demus on Deutsche Grammophon. I consider this life-enhancing Onyx set to be in the same elevated league. Beautiful, expressive and often haunting this timeless music is performed with the flaming power of a blast furnace. Throughout the set the glorious timbre of the Guadagnini and Mullova's imperious playing are intoxicating. This is a very special recording - one to treasure. I wouldn't be surprised if this became one of the great 'classics'. Michael Cookson see also review by Jens Laurson Of Bach’s Cello Suites, there has been such a plethora of recent recordings lately that greatness (Queyras) and extroverted excellence (Lipkind) relegated the merely superb (Klinger) and the very good (Gastinel) (never mind the dishwater variety — Isserlis) to shadowy spots they didn’t necessarily deserve and wouldn’t have received had the timing been better. Timing is excellent, however, for Viktoria Mullova’s Sonatas & Partitas because there hasn’t been an important recording issued since Julia Fischer’s (Pentatone) and Gidon Kremer’s on ECM in 2005, and Christian Tetzlaff’s on Hänssler in 2007. Her recording is big news, then, and better yet: it’s good news. In brief and thoughtful liner-notes that peel right through to the essence of why she added hers to the long list of violinists’ names on the Sonata & Partita roll call, she outlines her musical transformation as it relates to Bach. She has come from a decidedly old-school approach - she describes it as a sort of Russian robotic approach with continuous vibrato, sans liberties, and little articulation - to what is for all theoretical purposes a Historically Informed Performance account. She even plays with gut strings and a baroque bow, one or the other or both of which she has been doing for years in all repertoire where appropriate. Her recordings of the Beethoven and Mendelssohn Concertos are on gut string and she uses the baroque setup for her recent Bach and Vivaldi recordings. As with her latest Bach release and the Vivaldi concertos on Archiv, she is playing a 1750 Guadagnini (and a Walter Barbiero baroque bow) tuned to A=415, not her 1723 "Julius Falk" Stradivari. Listening to it at first, my first response to it was rather cool. Her playing is not always beautiful. Short bow strokes in the D minor Sarabande certainly don’t aim for prettiness. The sound is close, but with lots of room around her, direct but spacious, allowing the sound to bloom, and hiding nothing — for better and worse. I found it occasionally too close, leaving me with the feeling of standing a little too close to a painting that I admire. Her former rigor in Bach — perhaps even stiffness — is gone, although that approach I actually find myself appreciating. It wasn’t until direct comparison that the scales fell off my ears, revealing not only relative excellence but greatness. If upon the first few listens she didn’t seem to be delivering something truly out of the ordinary, now she shines. I matched her against Tetzlaff’s new recording and — difference of pitch apart — the dissimilarities are vast and instructive. The relative lack of ambience gives a yet more immediate, more contained impression of Tetzlaff’s instrument: presumably his modern Guarneri del Gesu copy by Peter Greiner. When listened to on its own, Tetzlaff’s Hänssler recording is striking to a degree, but the allure is lost: the violin sound comes across as squeaky, the playing constrained and lacking spontaneity. Mullova works hard to get momentum by way of her rather aggressive rhythmic dotting and double-stopping, enjoying the hard edges that Bach offers. Although it doesn’t quite sound like it, it feels more like Nathan Milstein than anyone else. The touches of gentleness amid that overt vigor betray the amount of thought put into making the recording, making Tetzlaff’s approach seem rather academic and deliberate (check the Siciliana) in comparison. Mullova really does play with guts — not just gut strings — which gives the Sonatas & Partitas a feel of being lived rather than just read. When Mullova is faster - throughout most of the First Sonata - she strikes as more pointed and lively. When she is slower (most extreme—4:04 to 2:21—in the first Double), less trying to master a technical challenge than communicating the spirit of the music. In the second Double, taken fast by both but faster still by Tetzlaff, the latter comes perilously close to sounding like a sewing machine. With first impressions manifesting themselves as hardened opinions, the differences between her and Tetzlaff, which I originally thought would be small despite Mullova’s quasi-HIP approach, became ever more obvious. Painfully so, after a while. After a while, the audio quality of the Hänssler recording gives you the impression of being thrown back 25 years. And the interpretation becomes more and more uninteresting. Not skipping ahead whenever it was Tetzlaff‘s turn grew ever more difficult. When Mullova came back on - say, with the A minor Fuga after Tetzlaff’s Grave - it felt like relief. That the differences are — or become — so striking, is all the more surprising since I cherish Tetzlaff in general and cherished his Bach in particular. This drop in appreciation isn’t just a matter of appreciating a particular interpretive style, either. And that’s despite some terrific instances on his part—the A minor Allegro, D minor Giga, and his Ciaconna among them. Spot-light comparisons with other favorite recordings did not yield the same discrepancies despite being very different from Mullova. My comparisons were: Milstein on DG, my eternal touchstone; Podger, my HIP-standard bearer; Fischer, my favorite among modern, honeyed versions. Especially Julia Fischer offers drastic contrast and yet she delights equally. Only Shlomo Mintz’s mellifluous account might be further from Mullova than Fischer. Mullova, for all her HIP-training and gear, will not replace Rachel Podger as the favorite of that particular approach: there is modern spirit to it all that makes it stand too tall and too proud to be a vehicle for the authenticists’ ideology. Nor will she end all arguments on style with this HIP-means/modern spirit approach. That’s incidentally not what a recording is intended or supposed to do. What Mullova will achieve, however, is as much a splash in the world of Sonata & Partita connoisseurs as Fischer created, and that by wonderfully different means. The time it took to get to appreciate, like, and finally love this recording was well invested. Jens F. Laurson “In this recording Viktoria Mullova presents virtually flawless playing but, of greater importance, she sustains an impeccably punctuated, modulated and compelling dialogue through Bach's counterpoint with seemingly effortless intimacy and charm.” BBC Music Magazine, May 2009 **** “Viktoria Mullova plays a gut-strung Guadagnini (in modern set-up) at low pitch, using a Baroque-style bow, so it's with the period instrument Bach recordings that Mullova can be most usefully compared. These are outstanding performances, however, whatever category they belong to. Mullova brings together several ideal qualities for a Bach player. Firstly, there's a secure sense of style, apparent equally in the rhythm and character of each of the Partitas' dances, and in the ornamented introductory movements of the first two Sonatas. Then there's her superior, virtuoso's technique, producing beautifully precise tuning and, in the fugal movements, finely controlled, varied and euphonious playing of the most densely polyphonic passages. To this we can add her deep musical understanding; by means of subtle emphasis and natural dynamic contrasts, she draws our attention to the beauty of Bach's harmonic progressions and to the balance and grandeur of his designs. Even on the few occasions where Mullova isn't entirely convincing the poise and sheer quality of the playing remains extremely persuasive. There have been many fine recent recordings of these works, but this one is definitely not to be missed.” Gramophone Classical Music Guide, 2010 “These are outstanding performances… Mullova brings together several ideal qualities for a Bach player. Firstly, there's a secure sense of style… Then there's her superior, virtuoso's technique, producing beautifully precise tuning and, in the fugal movements finely controlled, varied and euphonious playing of the most densely polyphonic passages. To this we can add her deep musical understanding; by means of subtle emphasis and natural dynamic contrasts, she draws our attention to the beauty of Bach's harmonic progressions and to the balance and grandeur of his designs.” Gramophone Magazine, May 2009 “Mullova's sense of an ongoing musical line is immaculate and totally unselfconscious, the authority of her performances is never in doubt.” The Guardian, 15th May 2009 **** “The virtuosity is stunning; the complex fugues in the C major and A minor sonatas are perfectly lucid, and the great D minor chaconne rises to an electrifying mid-point climax.” The Observer, 5th April 2009 “This set of Bach's six solo Sonatas and Partitas BWV1001-6 represents the first fruits of Mullova's full adoption of period tools of the trade alongside her assimilation of an apposite style of playing. And what remarkable discs they are. This is wonderfully fluent, absorbingly imaginative playing.” The Telegraph, 7th April 2009